Max Scherzer’s Intensity and Umpire Clashes Define His Blue Jays Journey
Few pitchers in modern baseball match the competitive intensity of Blue Jays’ veteran Max Scherzer. A three-time Cy Young Award winner and two-time World Series champion, Scherzer has long been known not just for his dominant pitching but also for his fiery demeanor on the mound. His fierce attitude often spills over into heated exchanges with MLB umpires—something that has become a defining part of his career.
In a recent game involving the Blue Jays, Scherzer wasn’t even pitching but still made headlines. With the score tied 2-2 and teammate Chris Bassitt handling the mound duties, Scherzer’s frustrations boiled over once again. This time, he took a sarcastic approach to express his displeasure with umpire CB Bucknor by mimicking a coin toss to mock how strike and ball decisions were being made.
This moment wasn’t just for laughs—it was a pointed jab at Bucknor, whose reputation for questionable calls is well known throughout the league. Bucknor has been consistently criticized for inconsistent strike zones and controversial decisions, even being voted the league’s worst umpire multiple times. Scherzer’s mockery added to a long history of player frustration toward Bucknor.
Their history dates back to 2015, when Bucknor made a controversial walk-off call that angered many, including Scherzer. The umpire ruled a game-winning hit fair without clearly seeing the play, a moment that likely still lingers in Scherzer’s memory.
Although Scherzer is currently on the injured list due to right thumb inflammation, his competitive edge remains sharp. He signed a one-year, $15.5 million deal with the Blue Jays in February 2025, but has been limited to only one start this season. That outing came against the Orioles, where he pitched three innings, gave up three hits, two earned runs, and struck out two batters. The start was promising, even if short-lived.
Since then, Scherzer has been working on his recovery and recently completed a “heavy bullpen” session—an encouraging sign that he could return soon. With the Blue Jays dealing with early-season pitching struggles, his comeback would be a crucial boost. His leadership, experience, and skill could not only strengthen the rotation but also guide younger pitchers through the season’s challenges.
Whether it’s delivering critical innings or challenging umpires with dramatic flair, Max Scherzer remains one of the most compelling figures in baseball. His return is eagerly awaited, and with it, possibly more unforgettable moments—both on the mound and in his ongoing battles with MLB’s officiating.