Jose Altuve’s Almost-Trade in 2013: How One Call Nearly Changed Astros History
When you hear the name Jose Altuve, it’s impossible not to think of the Houston Astros. For over a decade, he’s been their heartbeat—an MVP, a two-time World Series champion, and a fan favorite whose legacy seems inseparable from the franchise. But that legacy was almost erased before it even began.
<strong>The Trade That Nearly Happened</strong>
In 2013, former Kansas City Royals GM Dayton Moore revealed that Astros GM Jeff Luhnow once offered him a trade that could’ve rewritten baseball history: Jose Altuve for Royals first baseman Eric Hosmer. Moore, who shared the story on the Diggin’ Deep podcast, recalled receiving the offer during a Royals road trip in Houston. Sitting at a Starbucks, he picked up a call from Luhnow who floated the Altuve deal—but Moore passed, reluctant to part with a key part of the Royals’ core.
Both Altuve and Hosmer debuted in 2011. While Hosmer became a crucial part of Kansas City’s 2015 World Series run, Altuve’s rise was even more meteoric. Nine All-Star selections, an MVP award, and a reputation as one of the best second basemen in modern baseball all followed—along with two rings in Houston.
<strong>What If Altuve Left?</strong>
Had Moore agreed to that trade, the Astros would’ve lost not just a star but their foundation. Altuve has played a pivotal role in shaping the identity of the modern Astros. His clutch postseason performances, leadership in the locker room, and consistent bat have been cornerstones of Houston’s success.
A swap for Hosmer—while potentially still beneficial—might have robbed the Astros of their emotional leader. On the flip side, a Royals lineup with Altuve in it might have formed a dynasty of its own. The ripple effect would’ve stretched far across the league.
<strong>Fast Forward to 2025</strong>
This season, Altuve’s production has dipped below his career averages. He’s batting .256 with 4 home runs, 14 RBIs, and a .671 OPS—well below his career .305 average and .828 OPS. On May 10, he left a game against the Reds with hamstring tightness but returned two days later against none other than the Royals—his almost-destination.
Despite the numbers, Altuve’s influence remains immense. In late April, he voluntarily moved from the leadoff spot to the second slot to give rookie Jeremy Peña a chance to spark the offense. The result? Peña has been red-hot, batting .406 since the lineup switch. That selfless move embodies the veteran leadership Altuve brings—value that goes far beyond stats.
<strong>The Legacy That Almost Wasn’t</strong>
Altuve’s loyalty, resilience, and consistent excellence have made him a legend in Houston. But had one trade call gone differently in 2013, everything could have changed—for him, the Astros, and the Royals.
Baseball is a game of inches. Sometimes, it’s also a game of phone calls. And one call in 2013 could have rewritten the script for one of MLB’s most iconic players.