Edmonton Oilers Silence Doubters With Grit and Defense, but Questions Linger Ahead of Stars Clash
The Edmonton Oilers have become masters of the comeback this postseason. After battling back from deficits against the LA Kings and staging repeat rallies against the Vegas Golden Knights, they’ve racked up six straight comeback wins—a feat that’s both impressive and concerning. While their ability to flip games on their heads is undeniable, it’s also brought up uncomfortable questions about their defense.
For two straight games, goaltender Stuart Skinner and the Oilers’ defensive unit appeared to put those questions to rest. Skinner recorded back-to-back shutouts, quieting critics—for a moment. But ahead of their upcoming Western Conference Finals matchup with the Dallas Stars, doubts have resurfaced. When asked about the defense, Leon Draisaitl—who led the NHL in goals this season—couldn’t hide his irritation.
“I don’t know how many times we need to answer these questions.”
Leon Draisaitl expresses confidence in the Oilers’ defence heading into the Western Conference Final. 💪 pic.twitter.com/YARjI2w7fi
— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) May 19, 2025
“Yeah, very confident,” he responded bluntly when asked about his belief in the team’s defense. After a brief pause, he added, “I don’t know how many times we need to answer these questions.” He insisted that the Oilers have been a strong defensive unit for years, noting that in the NHL, expecting shutouts every night is unrealistic. “We’re a good, structured defensive team that can defend really well,” Draisaitl emphasized.
Captain Connor McDavid shared similar frustration when asked the same question after Game 5. “How many times are we gonna answer this question, really? Like honestly?” he shot back. McDavid, like Draisaitl, remains confident in the Oilers’ ability to defend—despite the doubts.
Draisaitl, known for his scoring, has also embraced defensive responsibilities this postseason. Ahead of the crucial Game 5 against Vegas, he told reporters, “I like to think that I can play any role you give me.” True to his word, he notched a critical assist in overtime, helping Kasperi Kapanen seal the win. “Whatever I’m needed to do, I’ll be doing,” the former Hart Trophy winner stated.
Goaltender Stuart Skinner has also stepped up, especially after facing scrutiny earlier in the series. In the last two games alone, Skinner saved 47 shots and showed significant improvement in positioning and composure under pressure. Once considered a liability, he now stands as one of the team’s most important assets heading into the conference final.
Still, the Oilers face their toughest test yet. The Dallas Stars, led by their so-called “New Finnish Mafia,” are on fire. Mikko Rantanen has delivered two playoff hat tricks, while Mikael Granlund added one against the Jets. Dallas is a deep, physical team with relentless offensive weapons, and if the Oilers’ defense isn’t airtight, they could be punished quickly.
While Edmonton’s comebacks have highlighted their resilience, they’ve also exposed areas that still need tightening. Whether their recent shutouts were a turning point or a temporary reprieve will be answered soon—on the ice, against one of the hottest offenses left in the playoffs.